Skip to content
SPM Tuition
Principles of Accounting · Books of prime entry

Choosing the correct journal

You understand debit and credit, but the first book you pick for a transaction is often wrong.

Two questions sort every transaction. First, did cash or a cheque move, or is it on credit? Second, is the item goods for resale, or something else?

This lesson belongs to books of prime entry. When you can choose the right book, the amounts are covered in recording sales, purchases and returns.

What are the six books?

Each book has one job.

Book What it records
Sales journal Goods sold on credit
Purchases journal Goods bought on credit for resale
Sales returns journal Goods returned by customers
Purchases returns journal Goods returned to suppliers
Cash book All money in and out, by cash or bank
General journal Everything else: assets on credit, write-offs, opening entries, corrections

Worked example: sorting eight transactions

Kedai Sinar records these transactions in March. Apply the two questions to each one.

  1. Sold goods on credit to Ali, RM540: sales journal.
  2. Bought goods on credit from Bakar Trading, RM800: purchases journal.
  3. Ali returned faulty goods worth RM54: sales returns journal.
  4. Returned goods worth RM100 to Bakar Trading: purchases returns journal.
  5. Received a cheque of RM400 from Ali: cash book.
  6. Paid RM300 cash for wages: cash book.
  7. Bought a computer on credit, RM2 500: general journal.
  8. Wrote off RM120 owed by Devi as a bad debt: general journal.

The traps are items 7 and 8. Both look like ordinary credit dealings, but neither involves goods for resale.

The mistake that costs marks

The common slip is to put any credit purchase in the purchases journal. The word “bought” pulls the answer there before the second question is asked.

Step Wrong Right
Item 7 book Purchases journal General journal
Effect on purchases Purchases overstated by RM2 500 Purchases unchanged
Item 7 account Debit Purchases Debit Computer (asset)

The fix is to ask whether the business will resell the item. A computer is used in the shop, not sold from it.

What if a transaction involves both cash and credit?

Split it. A sale of RM1 000 where the customer pays RM400 now and owes RM600 is a cash book entry of RM400 and a sales journal entry of RM600.

Each part goes to the book that fits its own nature.

Check yourself

Name the book for each: (a) goods sold on credit to Lim, RM300; (b) goods returned by Lim, RM60; (c) delivery van bought on credit, RM18 000; (d) rent paid by cheque, RM500.

Answer

(a) Sales journal. (b) Sales returns journal, because goods came back from a customer. (c) General journal, since a van is an asset and not goods for resale. (d) Cash book, since a cheque is a bank movement.

What to study next

Move on to recording sales, purchases and returns. Test yourself with the books of prime entry practice set.

If you want a teacher to hear your reasoning, see online one-to-one Accounting tuition.

Common questions

How do I know which journal to use?

Ask two questions. Did cash or a cheque move now, or is the transaction on credit? Then ask whether the item is goods for resale or something else. Cash goes to the cash book. Credit goods go to sales or purchases, and everything else goes to the general journal.

Why is a computer bought on credit not in the purchases journal?

The purchases journal is only for goods bought to resell. A computer is an asset the business keeps for use, so it is recorded in the general journal. Mixing the two inflates purchases and overstates the cost of goods sold.

Where is a bad debt written off recorded?

A bad debt write-off is not a sale, purchase or cash movement, so it goes through the general journal. The entry debits bad debts and credits the customer's account. The general journal handles all such adjustments.

If you pick the wrong book under exam pressure, one-to-one Accounting lessons let a teacher ask you the two questions aloud on your own examples until they become automatic.

  • Online one-to-one lessons for your child with an experienced teacher.
  • Your first class is a one-hour trial, from RM50. The fee is agreed before you book.
  • Happy with the teacher? Continue with lessons of about 1.5 hours. If not, ask for another teacher.