Skip to content
SPM Tuition
Principles of Accounting chapter guide

Profit, cost and cash are different questions

A question shows a profit and then asks about cash, and the two answers refuse to agree.

Profit, contribution and cash answer three different questions. Profit asks whether total income beat total costs, contribution asks what each unit adds, and cash asks whether money is available when a payment is due.

This series extends the chapter on cost and management accounting. It assumes you know the basics from calculating contribution and break-even point.

How does one sale show up three ways?

An invented business sells goods for RM1 000 on credit, and pays RM600 in cash for the goods sold. The customer pays in two months.

  • Profit question: the sale is recorded now, so revenue of RM1 000 less the RM600 paid out gives a gross profit of RM400.
  • Contribution question: selling price minus variable cost is what matters. If the RM600 is all variable cost, the sale adds RM400.
  • Cash question: cash has fallen by RM600 now, and the RM1 000 arrives later.

What are the four lessons?

Read them in this order, because each one fixes a different mix-up.

  1. Why a profitable business can run short of cash
  2. Separating contribution from profit using a supplied cost table
  3. Testing a break-even result against feasible sales capacity
  4. Building a cash budget without counting a receipt twice

Who should start where?

If a question mentions “cash balance” or “month”, start with lesson 1 or 4. If it gives a table of costs and asks for profit or contribution, go to lesson 2. If it asks whether a target is achievable, go to lesson 3.

When all four feel clear, use the integrated practice set and the cash profit and transaction timing explorer to test yourself.

For a teacher who can point out which word in a question decides the figure, see online one-to-one Accounting tuition.

Common questions

Why can a business make a profit and still run out of cash?

Profit counts a sale when it is made, but cash arrives only when the customer pays. Stock bought, assets purchased and loan repayments also use cash without being expenses in the same month.

What is the difference between contribution and profit?

Contribution is selling price minus variable cost. Profit is the total contribution minus all fixed costs. A product can have positive contribution and still lose money if fixed costs are too high.

Which lesson should I read first?

Start with the lesson on why a profitable business can have a cash shortage, then separate contribution from profit, then test break-even against capacity, and finish with the cash budget.

Do I need the earlier chapter first?

It helps to know cost types, break-even and a basic cash budget. The lessons here assume those and focus on telling the questions apart.

If you keep answering a cash question with a profit figure, a one-to-one Accounting lesson lets a teacher point at the exact word in the question that signals which figure to use.

  • Online one-to-one lessons for your child with an experienced teacher.
  • Your first class is a one-hour trial, from RM50. The fee is agreed before you book.
  • Happy with the teacher? Continue with lessons of about 1.5 hours. If not, ask for another teacher.