Skip to content
SPM Tuition
Manahij al-Ulum al-Islamiah · SPM subjects and learning resources

Examples versus evidence in a written explanation

Your explanations contain a lot of detail, yet you cannot tell which part the marker wants.

An example makes a point clear, and evidence makes it trustworthy. An explanation with only one of the two feels either vague or unsupported.

This lesson is part of the SPM subjects and learning resources section and follows connecting a term with an example and its evidence.

How are the two roles different?

An example answers the reader’s question, “What would this look like?” Evidence answers a different question: “How do you know?”

An example can be invented for practice, such as a school situation. Evidence cannot be invented, because it must point to a real source in your studied materials.

Example Evidence
Question answered What does it look like? How do you know?
Source A situation that fits the point Textbook, class discussion or approved material
Risk if missing The point stays abstract The point is only your opinion

Worked example: label each sentence

This is an original paragraph for practice, about why careful planning matters for a class project. Read it, then see the labels.

  1. Careful planning helps a group finish a project on time.
  2. For example, a group that lists tasks and dates on the first day can see which task is falling behind.
  3. The class discussion on shared responsibility made the same point: tasks work best when each person knows what they own.
  4. So planning turns a shared goal into clear individual duties.

Labels: sentence 1 is the point, sentence 2 is the example, sentence 3 is the evidence because it names a source the class studied, and sentence 4 is the link that closes the paragraph.

Repair an example-only paragraph

Here is a weaker version: “Careful planning helps a group. For example, a group lists tasks on day one. Another example is a group that shares a calendar.”

The paragraph has a point and two examples, but no evidence. Two examples do not double the support, because they answer the same question.

Repair: keep the first example, replace the second with a sentence of evidence from your notes, and add a closing link. The repaired paragraph has the four labels shown above.

A common mistake: calling an example evidence

A student might label “a group that lists tasks on day one” as evidence. It is an example, because it describes a situation and does not name a studied source.

Try this test. If another believable situation could take its place, the sentence is an example. If it must point to one particular source in your materials, it is evidence.

Check yourself

Label each sentence as point, example or evidence. (a) Checking a source helps prevent mistakes. (b) A student compares a message with the official school notice before replying. (c) The textbook section on careful sharing says claims should be checked first.

Answer

(a) is the point, because it states the claim in general terms.

(b) is an example, because it describes a situation that shows the point.

(c) is evidence, because it names a source in the studied materials.

What to study next

Use the structured-answer self-review tool to label the sentences of one of your own paragraphs, then rewrite the weakest one. If terms still feel unclear, go back to connecting a term with an example and its evidence.

If you want a teacher to go through your paragraphs with you, see online one-to-one Manahij Islamiah tuition. Assessment arrangements remain with your school.

Common questions

Can one sentence be both an example and evidence?

It can look that way, but each has a different job. An example describes a situation. Evidence names a source that supports the point. If a sentence does both, split it in two so each job is clear to the reader.

Which one should come first?

State the point first, then give the example, then the evidence. This order lets the reader see your claim before the support. Some answers put evidence first, which is fine if the point is still stated clearly.

What if my notes have no clear source for a point?

Ask your teacher which part of the textbook or class discussion covers it, and write the source beside the point in your notes. Do not invent a source. A careful answer uses only what was studied.

How many examples are enough?

One well-chosen example usually serves a short answer. A second example is only useful if it shows a different side of the point.

If you cannot tell whether a sentence is doing the work of an example or of evidence, one-to-one Manahij Islamiah lessons let a teacher label your own paragraphs with you and rebuild the weak ones.

  • Online one-to-one lessons for your child with an experienced teacher.
  • Your first class is a one-hour trial, from RM50. The fee is agreed before you book.
  • Happy with the teacher? Continue with lessons of about 1.5 hours. If not, ask for another teacher.