Skip to content
SPM Tuition
Study problem · Geography

Write an explanation, not a list of factors

You write three or four correct factors, but the marker still says your answer is only a list.

An explanation shows how each factor leads to the result. Turn every factor into a short chain of cause, process and effect, and the answer stops being a list.

This page sits in SPM Geography and pairs with explaining location factors. The claim, evidence and revision desk helps you check each answer afterwards.

What does this look like in real life?

You might write: “Port town Y grew because of a deep harbour, flat land, a river and roads.” Your teacher writes “explain how” in the margin. You reply: “But all four are right.”

They are right. They are also unfinished, because none of them shows how the factor produced growth.

Why does it happen?

Three habits cause it.

  • Revision notes are bullet lists, so the answer copies the bullets.
  • Time pressure makes naming factors feel faster than explaining them.
  • The linking step seems too obvious to write down.

A chain-building method

For each factor, write three short pieces in one or two sentences.

  1. Factor: what it is.
  2. Process: what it allows or changes.
  3. Effect: what happens to the outcome in the question.

Worked example

This is a worked example for a fictional port town, Pelabuhan Laut. The question: “Explain why the town grew.”

List answer. “Deep harbour, flat land, river, roads.”

Chain answer.

  • “The harbour is deep, so large cargo ships can dock without waiting for high tide, which attracts shipping companies and creates jobs at the port.”
  • “The land behind the port is flat, so warehouses and roads are cheaper to build, which lets businesses set up near the harbour.”
  • “A road leads inland, so goods can be moved from the port to other towns quickly, which raises the amount of trade passing through.”

Each chain answer uses a link word (so, which) that connects a factor to a result, and the explanation sits in those words.

List against chain

List Chain
“Flat land.” “Flat land makes building cheaper, so businesses set up nearby.”
“Roads.” “Roads let goods reach other towns, so more trade passes through the port.”
“Deep harbour.” “A deep harbour lets large ships dock at any time, so the port handles more cargo.”

What can you do this week?

  1. Take five past-style explain questions and write three chains for each.
  2. Circle the linking words in each chain. If there are none, it is still a list.
  3. Swap one factor at a time to check the chain still makes sense.
  4. Log the answers that stayed as lists in a mistake log.

When could one-to-one tuition help?

If chains still do not come easily, a teacher can read your sentences with you and ask “so what happens next?” until the link appears in your writing. Lessons are online and one-to-one.

See online one-to-one Geography tuition for how this works.

Common questions

Why is a list of factors not enough for an explain question?

Explain asks for reasons. A list gives facts but does not show how each one leads to the outcome. A marker needs to see the link, often through words like because, so or which means.

How long should each factor be?

Two or three sentences: name the factor, say what it does, then state the effect on the outcome. Three well-built factors usually beat six one-word items.

What linking words help?

Because, which means, so, as a result, therefore and this leads to. They force you to write the step between the cause and the effect, which is what the marks reward.

Do I need an example in every factor?

Only if the question asks. Otherwise use one relevant example in the answer, checked for accuracy. A single clear example is better than many uncertain ones.

If your answers stay at the listing stage, one-to-one Geography lessons can practise turning each factor into a full chain on your own questions.

  • Online one-to-one lessons for your child with an experienced teacher.
  • Your first class is a one-hour trial, from RM50. The fee is agreed before you book.
  • Happy with the teacher? Continue with lessons of about 1.5 hours. If not, ask for another teacher.