Skip to content
SPM Tuition
Learning route

Electrical reasoning from diagrams and measurements

You can calculate in circuits, but questions asking you to explain a diagram leave you stuck.

Reasoning questions give a circuit, a graph or a table and ask you to predict or explain. It is part of SPM Physics electricity and has four lessons and a practice set.

What does this section cover?

Start with predicting what an open branch changes in a conceptual circuit. Then compare potential difference readings without changing the circuit.

The third is explaining a non-linear current-voltage graph from supplied measurements. The last is separating electrical energy from power in a fictional appliance table. The practice set mixes all four.

One circuit, four kinds of question

Take this original example. A 6 V supply feeds two identical lamps in parallel, each of resistance 12 Ω.

Question type What you are asked Key idea
Open branch What happens if one lamp is removed? The other branch still has 6 V
Comparing readings What does each voltmeter show? Same p.d. across parallel branches
Graph from data Why is V ÷ I not constant for a lamp filament? Resistance rises with temperature
Energy and power Which appliance uses more energy? Energy depends on power and time

Each branch carries 0.5 A, so the supply delivers 1.0 A. Remove one lamp and the supply delivers 0.5 A, while the remaining lamp stays as bright as before.

Who should start where?

If you are unsure what changes when a switch opens, begin with the open-branch lesson. If voltmeter readings confuse you, begin with comparing readings.

If a curved graph shows up in your paper, begin with the non-linear graph lesson. If kWh and watts keep blurring, begin with the energy and power table lesson.

For a teacher to go through your written answers, see online one-to-one Physics tuition or try the one-hour trial class (from RM50).

Common questions

What is different about reasoning questions?

They ask you to predict, compare or explain using a diagram, graph or table, usually with a short written answer. Marks are for the correct physical idea and a clear link to the evidence supplied.

Do I need to do calculations in these questions?

Sometimes a short calculation proves your point, such as finding V ÷ I at two points. Use numbers from the question to support the explanation instead of writing general statements.

How do I write a good explanation?

State what changes or stays the same, give the physical reason in one sentence, and refer to the data or diagram. Keep each sentence to one idea, so a marker can find each mark.

If your calculations are sound but your explanations lose marks, one-to-one Physics lessons let a teacher read your written reasons and show which idea each sentence of the answer needs.

  • Online one-to-one lessons for your child with an experienced teacher.
  • Your first class is a one-hour trial, from RM50. The fee is agreed before you book.
  • Happy with the teacher? Continue with lessons of about 1.5 hours. If not, ask for another teacher.